Saturday, December 19, 2015

The "Problem" of Evil, II

"But I can easily imagine a world without evil! It would be perfect."

"No, it has a very grave defect: it is imaginary. No one can live and nothing can exist in an imaginary world!"

A world with only good and no evil may be like a world with only up and no down: purely impossible.

But until you can make your own universe, it is not appropriate to criticize someone else's!


  1. I can imagine a world with no evil. I cannot imagine a world with an up and no down.

    1. Yes. That world you imagine has a grave defect: it is imaginary. Can you make it real?

    2. I was thinking more along the lines of necessary and contingent truths. A world with up but no down is nonsensical like a four-sided triangle. A world without evil is at least logically possible.

    3. Maybe it is logically possible. I'm not so sure.


An orgy

“The advancement of science and the rationality of politics are interwoven in a social process that, in the perspective of a more distant f...