Downsides to open borders?

7 comments:

  1. Gene, you can't be serious? Do you really think this clash of the cultures thing is real?

    I'm honestly not sure how to interpret the data. The first thing that comes to mind is that the "multiculturalism" did do it, but that this is not an essential part of it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What?! Cultures are different. The results of making Sweden multicultural are real. What exactly is "not serious" about admitting this?

      Delete
    2. Of course cultures are different. I'd be an idiot if I denied that (I also do not think all cultures or, rather, all cultural practices, are equal). That doesn't necessarily mean that two of them are going to react like water and sodium if they mix together. This idea always seemed like a conservative bogeyman to me. Now, I don't deny that certain mixtures can react badly (think liberal America and Islamic fundamentalist Saudi Arabia), but I don't think is inherent to multiculturalism. I'm also not sure how Sweden made itself multicultural through legislation. (Was it a declaration? A change in certain crime statutes?)

      Delete
    3. "This idea always seemed like a conservative bogeyman to me. "
      So when a particular example crops up -- and we see this problem with attitudes to women in public and rape all over the world now (Gene could have cited Rotherham) -- how do you react to the fact? Not like Keynes it seems.

      Delete
    4. "Not like Keynes it seems."

      Uh, what? My knowledge of economics topics is basic, so I'm probably missing something here.

      Delete
  2. Do you draw a distinction between multiculturalism and diversity? And why do you think multiculturalism leads to destructive results?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Samson, my post was on immigration.

      Delete