I decided to move some discussion from this post up to the top level here. Specifically, Watoosh wrote: "Well, if violence is defined as initiation of force (which, of course, presupposes certain property rights), then I think Rockwell is correct..." Well, if we define cats as elephants, then many people keep elephants in their house. More seriously, firstly, violence is not usually defined that way. It's defined as, you know, violence, so that, say, someone may respond violently or non-violently to someone who aggresses against them. Otherwise, it would make no sense to say, for instance, "He punched me, but I did not stoop to violence in response." And, secondly, the libertarian usage of "initiation of force" is very offbeat. If I wander onto someone's meadow, most people would not say I had "initiated force" -- I mean, sure, I used "force" against the earth to push off walking, but that's not force directed against...
That's it?
ReplyDeleteYou should have kept it a mystery.
Cool, I didn't realize you had so many co-authors. But I think you struck a low blow with this one:
ReplyDelete“Histoy Is Not Geography: A Critique of Jared Diamond,” forthcoming from Imprint Academics, volume of papers from 2006 Michael Oakeshott Association Conference.
Diamond overreaches at times, I grant you, but I seriously doubt he claimed that geography was his toy.
Dr. Murray, lot's of hot air and no action -- I asked you where you had published months ago, and we ain't seen shit yet.
ReplyDeleteBob, don't you remember the day you called me "the slut of the Austrian economics world"?
ReplyDeleteFunny you bring my publshing up. I am currently reading Economics for Real People.
ReplyDeleteAnd my review of it will appear in a major publiication:)
Oh yeah...I'm glad I didn't recycle the joke!
ReplyDeleteA scholarly journal, Dr. Murray? And that's all you have to offer?
ReplyDeleteHey, I know of people who have published far more than me, but I'm pretty happy with what I've put out in about 5 years of scholarly work. If you have just this one publication, what in the world would prompt you to ask me if "that's it"?
Dr. Murray, put up or shut up!
For what it's worth, I thought Dr. T was making a joke. It may not have been very funny, but then neither was I when I called Stephan an "ass" on the other thread.
ReplyDeleteAnd anyway, a book review doesn't count. You're supposed to keep those clearly marked on your CV because other people will laugh at you if you try to pass off a book review as a publication in the journal listed.
Final point (for now): And what's really funny, is Dr. T. proving he's a bigger scholar than Gene, by saying he is working on a review of...Gene's book.
ReplyDeleteI'm not mocking you in this paragraph, Dr. T. Are you really a doctor, and of what? I can't remember if I already asked you this on the "Gene's a loser" thread...
The page is so wonderful that I want to write something about myself.
ReplyDeleteI get a lot of rohan crone and the rohan gold is very important for anyone who wants to play the net game. Most of the rohan online croneis the access to the net game. If you have the rohan online gold, you can make good use of the rohan moneyto enjoy yourself in the game.