I decided to move some discussion from this post up to the top level here. Specifically, Watoosh wrote: "Well, if violence is defined as initiation of force (which, of course, presupposes certain property rights), then I think Rockwell is correct..." Well, if we define cats as elephants, then many people keep elephants in their house. More seriously, firstly, violence is not usually defined that way. It's defined as, you know, violence, so that, say, someone may respond violently or non-violently to someone who aggresses against them. Otherwise, it would make no sense to say, for instance, "He punched me, but I did not stoop to violence in response." And, secondly, the libertarian usage of "initiation of force" is very offbeat. If I wander onto someone's meadow, most people would not say I had "initiated force" -- I mean, sure, I used "force" against the earth to push off walking, but that's not force directed against...
sue me?
ReplyDeleteThis is supposed to be Soparno talk? Keep watchin youngsta, you got a long way to go.
Not sure what you mean, Gene. The "woke up this morning" reminds me of a Doors song, and the "sue me" part reminds me of a Prince song.
ReplyDeleteIs that what you had in mind?
Don't know, Bob, but you can call me Deacon Blues.
ReplyDeleteNo, Sidney, it's not.
ReplyDeleteTokyoTom wins the prize.
Thanks, Gene!
ReplyDeleteIt seems that the tricky part, for sidney and Bob at least, was to understand the question.
If I may venture, the "woke up this morning, got myself a gun" was very definitely the Sopranos theme song, as Gene acknowledged. That leaves the rest as what Gene intended by that.